Log me on automatically each visit
It is currently Thu Aug 18, 2022 11:34 am
Post a new topic Post a reply  [ 1 post ]   
Author Message
 Post subject: 10,000 hour rule
PostPosted: Wed Jun 03, 2015 3:25 pm 
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Wed May 27, 2015 10:20 am
Posts: 503
You know, I often look upon novices who want to train horses with a degree of amusement, if not disdain. They want it right now, damn the consequences! To them, the key is getting a state trainer's license! I suppose I was no different in wanting to legally train horses as soon as possible in my long ago youth, but I was smart enough to know that I really needed to sweat in the trenches (shedrows of many tracks) and learn those everyday lessons on the race track even though I had been around horses since I was six, maybe equating to over 20 years of general equine past experience. I could really only be called a "race trainer" or practice that trade, proficiently, if I had actually lived it as a groom for many years.

I would like to re-post below, a post written this morning by Paul Berger, an herbalist, on who is a master herbalist. The same would apply to what makes a master racehorse trainer. The 10,000 hour rule is pretty easy to rack up fast in a profession like ours that require most grooms to live with their horses 24/7, less so with exercise riders or jocks who ride a few hours a day. The real trainer will spend many, many hours in their barn and be almost as efficient in learning as the lowly groom. Many won't, prefering to drive their jag in for morning works and racing in the grandstand.

There are no short-cuts. I have found this to be true and most stewards know it too.

"Mastery of any topic is attained after years to decades of becoming fully engaged not only in the field, but being constantly engaged with a level of rigor and practice that steadily expands and also deepens understanding of the facts and principles of that field or topic. Themaster brings the subject completely alive in their own being and experience. Ultimately their career is characterized by various "threshhold events" of understanding and insight which contribute new understanding for the current generation and a legacy for future generations. Those thresholds are made possible by an intuitive synthesis of many facts and observations during the career leading up to them. This process among the teachers and leaders and innovators in a field is how that field stays current and alive throughout generations.

The 10,000 hour rule

A study of classical musicians at a Berlin academy of classical music investigated students in three tracks in the school: The Star track, headed for world fame in classical music; the middle track, headed for the St Louis Philharmonic; and the teacher track, less skilled and headed to teach music in high school. Researchers asked the simple question: How much weekly practice time have you put in year by year since your started playing your instrument? The results: star track musicians had put in at least 10,000 hours of practice. The middle track had put in 8,000 hours but none had put in 10,000 hours; and the teacher track had put in 4,000 hours, but none had put in 8,000 hours. This is now being called The Ten Thousand Hour Rule in popular culture, and people are claiming mastery for having showed up for work for 10,000 hours (about 20 hours a week for ten years.) There is a big problem with this kind of thinking, however. Musicians put in practice time with rigor such as scales, mastering all keys, and chords within them, as well as developing progressively more difficult techniques and progressively more sophisticated pieces for performance, while at the same time keeping well practiced in the basics. They don't just play what they already know, they grow constantly, in addition to constantly honing the basics. Just punching the clock is not enough. I am sure the a Rotor Rooter Man can claim 10,000 hours of snaking toilets, but this is not progressive development of ability and insight. Or to put it another way, one stand-up comic criticized a rival saying: "He says he's been doing stand-up for twenty years; I say he only did it for 1 year and then repeated that year nineteen times." In the herbal field, we have herbalists lecturing at conferences who are giving essentially the same lectures they were 20 years ago; herbalist-physicians practicing by rote administration of set formulas; herbalists writing books full of information they read in other books and which they have never demonstrated to be true in their own experience. So our questions for mastering herbalism are:

1) What kinds of activities or study count toward the 10,000 hours and progressively develop skill and insight in the practitioner?

2) How can we avoid becoming comedians who repeat their same jokes for twenty years without growing or developing new repertoire.

In this series of articles, I am not calling for standards for licensing or approval by any regulatory body or accrediting agency. I am an educator, with 36 years of clinical experience, 20 years teaching, and 15 years running a teaching clinic, supervising thousands of cases over that time in addition to my own clients. I'm now in my elder years, eligible for social security, and at this stage I could care a fig whether the government or anyone else approves of me. And I am very much focused on how to train a younger generation of herbalists in the routines and practices and attitudes that will lead to mastery instead of decades of bad jokes. I believe the future of Western herbalism will depend on this kind of work to a much greater extent than reframing what and who we are for the sake of acceptance by authority, however necessary or valuable that may seem in the short term.

Please feel free to reprint or circulate this article freely.
Paul Bergner"

OfflineProfileReply with quote
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post a new topic Post a reply  [ 1 post ] 

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
Search for:
Jump to: